Stanton on Health Care Cost Control Bill

It is a bad habit to think that if government has intruded its hand into a particular commodity and that commodity begins or continues to sink that the solution calls for a heavier hand.

In one of their last minute “Hail Mary” passes before the end of the legislative session, Beacon Hill passed a 300+ page bill designed to contain health care costs.  With little debate and little more than 14 hours to read such a novel of a bill, continues and adds to Massachusetts’ top-down approach of policy makers and political insiders controlling the health care market.

As the bills length implies, it does nothing but add more bureaucracy to the health care system, indeed it adds a whole new state-run regulatory office.  Housing and Economic Development Secretary Greg Bialecki has stated that the new Massachusetts health care system may include more jobs outside of hospitals than the current system, those jobs he was talking about may just be for this new agency.

Additionally, this alleged cost control bill does nothing to contain costs.  In fact, you can expect costs to rise and quality of care to fall.  As the Wall Street Journal points out, under this new law, “all Massachusetts doctors, hospitals and other providers must register with a new state bureaucracy as a condition of licensure—that is, permission to practice.” A special Health Policy Commission board consisting of an eleven-member board “will use the data to set and enforce rules to ensure that total Massachusetts health spending, public and private, grows no more than projected gross state product through 2017.” In order to do so, the new board forbids these registered providers (i.e. hospitals and doctors) from making “any material change to its operations or governance structure” without the commission's approval.

What this means is that the entire healthcare system in Massachusetts will be under the thumb of Beacon Hill as it imposes a one-size-fits-all policy on every hospital in the state.  This bill kills any attempt at innovation and efficiency as anything that is outside the confines of the dictated measures of Beacon Hill will be heavily fined and risk losing licensure.

This further consolidation in the market will only exacerbate one of the main causes of the healthcare cost predicament we find ourselves in today. By denying consumers choice and a variety to that choice, the law serves only to make healthcare matters worse as it reduces the operating flexibility both in the form of care and in regards to finances, as credit rating agencies like Moody’s hint at downgrading the credit rating of Massachusetts hospitals because of this bill.

The Pioneer Institute draws a perfect distinction between the reforms offered in this bill and the real reforms needed to reduce healthcare costs; “Rather than provide financial incentives for individual patients to take charge of their own medical care, this legislation rearranges the system based on accountable care organizations (ACOs) and governmentally-imposed changes in payment methods.”

Massachusetts already spends more per capita on health care than any other state, quite possibly more than any other industrialized nation in the world.  When adjusted for higher wages and academic medical centers, the healthcare costs in Massachusetts are15% higher than the national average.  With this new bill we can only expect that percentage to increase.

There is a reason we call doctors “Doctors” and politicians “Politicians” and we would do well not to blur this distinction.  It is foolish to try to conform healthcare to the designs of government rather than to allow the healthcare industry to conform itself to the designs of healthcare.  The debilitating and lumbering bureaucracy should not be in charge of a system that requires nimbleness and ingenuity like health care.

Yet, sadly, it seems that Beacon Hill is set in its ways and has formed some pretty bad habits.  It is a bad habit, perhaps even a trademark of insanity, to think that if government has intruded its hand into a particular commodity and that commodity begins or continues to sink that the solution calls for a heavier hand.

It is time we tried withdrawing government’s hand in the realm of healthcare and get the industry out from under the thumb of Beacon Hill.  Real reform is needed; not simply old tricks amplified to look like new ideas.  In order to get it we need new people with new ideas who aren’t afraid to stand up to the status quo.

This post is contributed by a community member. The views expressed in this blog are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Patch Media Corporation. Everyone is welcome to submit a post to Patch. If you'd like to post a blog, go here to get started.

Joyce Kidd September 02, 2012 at 02:42 AM
It has been said by a resident of a communist country, to control the people, control their health care. Is iwhere we are heading? Thank you, Francis, for highlighting this hidden legislation, Best of luck in the election, We need you in office! Joyce and Jim Kidd
Jack Smith September 02, 2012 at 03:37 AM
He made some great points, we need more people like Francis Stanton
Stephen Escandon September 02, 2012 at 07:53 PM
china, North Korea, Cuba, Laos, Vietnam
x September 04, 2012 at 12:59 AM
Nice work Francis. Keep reading the Wall Street Journal and passing along facts never to be revealed in the Boston Globe. It should come as no surprise that most Massachusetts residents are unaware of, or do not care about, this sure-to-fail effort to control costs or improve healthcare. Reverend E. Raleigh Pimperton III
Jay Dwyer September 04, 2012 at 01:34 AM
Back to the future with "wage and price controls" and a whole new Hacharama to be filled with "the least of the least" found after a "nationwide search". The unique strength that built our country....and yes We Did Build This .....is open markets and Competition ! When you go to a grocery store there are a dozen choices of milk for every possible preference that no government agency could Ever conceive of. It's the same with any other product. Francis has done the hard, detailed work of reading the bill ( How refreshing is that ). An intelligent man with the ability to clearly translate the BS from Beacon Hill into English is what we need. The "leadership" on Beacon Hill has done such a great job that Taxpayers are leaving this state in droves and Taxtakers are moving in. "When someone isn't doing the job....We gotta let'em go" . Voting for Francis Stanton is a great step in the right direction. Let's


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »